Teal lake water beside a manicured curving lawn, mature palms and understated stucco homes in a Scottsdale planned community.

What HOA Dues Actually Buy in Gainey Ranch and McCormick Ranch

The two master association bills in ZIP 85258 look very different. The McCormick Ranch Property Owners' Association set its 2026 residential annual assessment at $265 for the whole year. The Gainey Ranch Community Association's 2026 master assessment is $361 a month, according to the association's published schedule for The Estates. That works out to $4,332 a year, about 16 times the McCormick Ranch figure.

If you're deciding between the two communities, that gap is the wrong number to compare. In both places the master fee is only the first line of the bill. The second line is a smaller association specific to your street or building, and it decides what you'll actually pay. Once both lines are counted, the yearly totals come much closer, and some McCormick Ranch addresses cost more to carry than a home inside Gainey Ranch's gates.

Two bills from one ZIP code

Here is how the two structures compare, using each association's own published figures.

Gainey Ranch McCormick Ranch
Master association Gainey Ranch Community Association McCormick Ranch Property Owners' Association
2026 master fee $361 per month $265 per year
Master fee two years earlier $327 per month in 2024 $255 per lot in 2024
Second layer One of eighteen satellite associations Neighborhood sub-associations, where a property has one
Example second-layer dues The Estates: $300 per month in 2026 Veritas at McCormick Ranch: $705 per month; Paseo Villas: $443 per month

The McCormick Ranch sub-association figures are the monthly assessments displayed on the Veritas at McCormick Ranch and Paseo Villas pages run by Vision Community Management. Those pages show no effective date next to the amounts, so confirm the current figure with the association before you write an offer.

Run the yearly math and the order changes. A home in The Estates at Gainey Ranch carries $661 a month in combined dues in 2026, or $7,932 for the year. At the displayed Veritas rate, a McCormick Ranch owner there pays $8,460 a year to the sub-association plus $265 to the master, for $8,725. At Paseo Villas the same arithmetic comes to $5,581. That puts a gated Gainey Ranch address between two McCormick Ranch addresses, which the master fees alone would never suggest.

What the Gainey Ranch master fee pays for

Gainey Ranch's master fee is large because the master association does work that elsewhere falls to each owner or each building. The GRCA's Who We Are page says each satellite association is required by the governing documents to employ the GRCA for landscape and building maintenance within its community. The same page says monthly assessments are set by dividing each association's budgeted cash requirement by its number of memberships. There are 1,035 residential memberships, counted one per lot or unit, and all GRCA members pay the same master amount on top of their satellite's dues.

The association's 2024 audited financial statements show where that money went for the year ended December 31, 2024. Spending included $817,988 on security, $1,804,125 on landscape maintenance and $399,051 on building maintenance. The same audit split that year's $327 monthly master assessment into $228.05 for operations, $63.45 for security, $19.50 for future major repairs and replacements, and $16 for future capital improvements. Security alone was roughly a fifth of the 2024 master fee.

Here is what that looks like on the ground. Gainey Ranch has three staffed security plazas, electronic gates at its other residential entries, and a security force and roving patrol on duty around the clock, according to the GRCA's security page. The association's amenities page also lists Cox cable and internet service, security monitoring, landscaping and condominium building maintenance. For a buyer, the cable and internet line means a recurring household bill is partly covered by dues.

The shared amenity is the Estate Club, the former Gainey family home converted for community use. It has a 10,000-square-foot clubhouse, a pool, a fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, social rooms and a bar.

Why the McCormick Ranch master fee stays small

McCormick Ranch's master association looks after a very large common area for a small yearly charge. The MRPOA's 2026 Rancher newsletter describes 11 lakes, more than 20 miles of walking paths and 15 pocket parks. The association's documents page puts the common area at 184 acres and the lakes at 120 acres. It also says the association maintains trees in its common areas and in Scottsdale medians under maintenance agreements. Named parks include Comanche, Mountain View and Shoshone. Next door is the City of Scottsdale's Indian Bend Wash Greenbelt, an 11-mile corridor of parks, lakes, paths and golf courses.

The master fee has also risen slowly. It went from $255 per lot in 2024 to $265 in 2026, an increase of about 4 percent over two years. Over the same period, Gainey Ranch's master assessment went from $327 to $361 a month, about 10 percent, while The Estates satellite held at $300 each year. The biggest current McCormick Ranch project is landscape work on Hayden Road, covering about 1.25 miles from Indian Bend Road to Via de Ventura Road. It includes irrigation, planting and shade-canopy work. The MRPOA's project page says the permit was obtained in the fourth quarter of 2025 and describes the work as budgeted under the association's Landscape Master Plan.

Reading the second line in a buyer's market

This matters more this fall because buyers have more room to negotiate. Citywide figures in the Scottsdale REALTORS® October 2026 market report show 5.45 months of inventory for October, up 11.22 percent from September. That month had 2,711 active listings at month-end, a 96.8 percent sold-to-list ratio and a $964,500 median sold price. The September 2026 report showed 4.57 months of inventory and a 97 percent sold-to-list ratio. Across Greater Phoenix, The Cromford Report showed a Market Index of 63.5 on November 14, 2026, with supply at 112.7 and demand at 71.6. Cromford's definitions treat a Market Index below 100 as a buyer's market. These are citywide and metro numbers, not figures for 85258 alone, but they describe the market both communities sell into.

With supply rising, comparable homes in the two communities can end up close in price, and the dues become the larger difference between them. A buyer weighing a Gainey Ranch villa against a McCormick Ranch townhome is choosing between two bundles. One combines the gate, the patrol, maintained grounds and cable in a single higher bill. The other pairs 120 acres of lakes for $265 a year with a sub-association whose dues, at the displayed rates, run from $443 a month at Paseo Villas to $705 at Veritas.

Dues figures here are general information for comparison, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm the current assessments and what they cover for any specific property with the association and your own advisors.

Frequently asked questions

Does every Gainey Ranch home pay $661 a month? No. Every GRCA member pays the same master assessment, $361 a month in 2026, plus the dues of their own satellite association. The $661 total belongs to The Estates. Each of the other satellites sets its own budget.

Is the Hayden Road project tied to a special assessment in McCormick Ranch? The MRPOA describes the Hayden Road landscape work as budgeted under its Landscape Master Plan, and its project page lists no special assessment.

Where can I see each association's finances? The GRCA posts its audited statements publicly, including the 2024 audit cited above. The MRPOA's documents page says its budget and latest reserve study are available to members after login.

If you're comparing a Gainey Ranch satellite with a McCormick Ranch sub-association, Karen's Collection would be glad to look at the two bills with you for the addresses on your list. Request a Concierge Consultation before you choose a street, and we'll go through the second line together. You can also explore more about Gainey Ranch and McCormick Ranch.

Work With Karen

While media clients and homeowners are different customers, the negotiating, marketing, and sales skills she has cultivated over the years benefit her buyers and sellers. For more information on Winnetka and Scottsdale real estate, contact Karen Stroble today!

Follow Me on Instagram